Player A’s highest ranking on one of the judge’s lists was 12th. For example, imagine two players were tied for 17th. In the case of the two players having the same exact point total, the tie was broken based on which of the tied players received the single highest ranking from one of the judges. The player with the 25th highest point value was named the 25th Greatest Halo Player of All Time.
The player with the highest total point value was named the Greatest Halo Player of All Time. Then, the points were tallied up for each of the players to create the final and official Top 25 list. The 25th player on each of their lists received 1 point, and the 1st player on each of their lists received 25 points. A panel of judges outside of the HCS team and across all Halo generations were selected and tasked with creating their own individual Top 25 lists.
